We’ve all been there, someone is having a difficult time or they tell you about something hard in their lives and you really want to comfort them. It can be hard to know what to say when someone is going through a hard time, but sentences that start with “at least” are often the opposite of comforting apart from in a few very specific contexts.
As someone who has been dealing with chronic illnesses and pain for a long time and someone who has been very open with my journey since adulthood, I have heard a lot of “at least”. They have included
- At least its not “insert illness perceived to be worse”
- At least you have a partner
- At least you have money (I don’t but that’s not the point)
- At least you get to stay home all the time
- At least you don’t have to work
- At least you are young
- At least you can do X activity
A lot of the time people mean well when they say these things, but sometimes people genuinely think you’re lucky because you don’t “have” to work and they do, or they think that your condition isn’t as bad as theirs, or that there are other conditions worse than what you have.
I am going to try to debunk some of these and explain why even if they were true, they still wouldn’t be helpful
At least its not “insert illness perceived to be worse”
There are a few reasons this isn’t a great thing to say, for a start its really dismissive, illness, pain and suffering are all relative, someone could be having the worst pain of their lives, it doesn’t matter if you think you have been through worse, if its the hardest thing they have been through, then its the hardest thing for them and that is valid. Even if they have been through worse in the past, they are allowed to find “easier” things just as tough to deal with.
Secondly, illnesses and suffering isn’t a competition, everyone is allowed to struggle , everyone has their own battles and they are entitled to support, no matter what other people are dealing with.
Thirdly, diagnosis alone does not dictate how much pain someone is in or how sick they are, or what other circumstances they have in their lives that could make things difficult. There are people out there with diagnoses that are perceived to be “worse” than mine who are actually much healthier overall and have a better quality of life. I also know of people who have diagnoses which are perceived to be less serious than mine who happen to be much sicker than me. The point is, the name of the illness alone does not tell us how sick someone is. Regardless, diagnosis does not dictate how much someone is going to suffer, it doesn’t tell people how much pain you are in, how much you can eat, how much medication you need to function, how difficult things are in their home lives, how difficult accessing care is or anything else that could impact their situation.
At least you have a partner
This is something I get a lot, usually from healthy people who just happen to be single. Don’t get me wrong, I absolutely love my fiance and I am very blessed to have someone in my life who loves me and who actually means the vows “In sickness and in health”.
However, the people who say this to me know nothing about my relationship or if its healthy or not, they just think I am lucky to be in a relationship and some of them even behave as if being in a relationship somehow makes being sick OK or not as life changing.
I am very, very blessed that I have someone who is supportive, kind and compassionate, but, maintaining a relationship when you’re really sick isn’t easy. Relationships in general need a lot of patience, understanding and hard work from both sides. When one of you is severely unwell, you both have to work even harder to keep communication open, to not get ratty with each other when you’re both running on no sleep. It is hard for me sometimes not to get short tempered when my pain is through the roof and I have not slept more than an hour or two for weeks at a time. It’s also very hard for my partner, he has to always be in reach of his phone incase I have an emergency, he keeps a medication list on his phone incase I ever end up in hospital unconscious and he needs to communicate it to doctors, and there are things other couples do every day that we are just unable to do together because of my limitations. The likelihood is that my health will get worse as i get older, and I am already well on my way to getting osteoporosis. He will watch me getting sicker the older we get, loosing more and more function and independence and that is going to be incredibly difficult for him.
To be brutally honest I also find some things more difficult, as when i am thinking about my illnesses I also have to think about him, and our future as a couple, rather than just about my illnesses/me. I have no problem with this at all, I adore my fiance and I would walk through fire pits to be with him. The compromises and thought needed to maintain the relationship are absolutely worth it and I will never begrudge that. I just think it’s something people underestimate, being in a relationship is amazing most of the time, but it is a lot of hard work.
At least you have money
This comment usually comes from people who live in less advantaged countries, who see that I am from the UK and automatically assume that I have lots of money and that this can fix everything.
There are two major things here – firstly I actually have no money, without my mother I would be homeless, I have no income and no way of getting one. Government help for people who are disabled and/or chronically unwell is very hard to access, and it’s very little money. I have access to one benefit, and it’s barely enough to buy the extra things that come with my conditions – gluten free food, skin care for my eczema, a comfortable pair of crutches, splints and other things that generally make my life more comfortable.
Secondly, even people who do have money can’t buy health, you might be able to buy a nicer wheelchair or a more accessible home, you might be able to pay for carers or a big car and a driver that can take you anywhere, but you can’t buy a cure that doesn’t exist yet, you can’t buy pain relief that takes away all pain, you can’t cure your paralysis with money or make things magically accessible in the outside world. Having money may make some things easier, like making sure you get enough food, making sure you have heating and food, but it doesn’t actually make being sick better or easier, and its not ok to tell someone with a serious illness that they should just be glad they have more money than you.
At least you get to stay home all the time / at least you don’t have to work
i have tied these together because they often go hand in hand. People who work/go to school/go out a lot often dream of being bale to just sit around doing nothing. This is because when you have a busy life and are always on the go, having a few days of just doing what you want, spending the day on the sofa or watching movies or whatever it may be, and people think that if you don’t work because of illnesses it’s the same thing. Unfortunately it really isn’t. When you have time off from school or work and you’re feeling well, you can do anything you want provided it is in your budget, you can have fun, you can see your friends and family, and if you have a day in bed or on the sofa its because you choose to. When you are chronically ill and sick enough to be unable to work, it also means you are often unable to do most of the things other people take for granted, people who are chronically unwell often get tired much easier, we are often in pain, some of us find eating and drinking harder and the majority have lots of health related admin and tasks to do. I personally have to make frequent phone calls to medical and admin staff, monitor and administer multiple different types of medications including injections, maintain my hydration the best I can and try to eat enough to keep my weight at a safe amount.
Then there’s the issue of finance, because I can’t work I have very little money, the money I do have goes on essentials that are mainly health related, and I can’t afford to do lots of fun activities. I also don’t have access to a car, and no one who is close enough to me to care has a car big enough for my wheelchair, so I am restricted to activities that I can get to by bus. The buses here only go to 2 locations and are every hour, so they are really inaccessible to someone with difficulty standing or walking for long periods as if you miss one you have an hour wait for the next. I am also at very high risk for infections due to the medications that keep me alive, so that makes it really dangerous for me to do certain activities. For the past 4 years my home has been the only safe place for me, but at times it has been more of a prison as I am quite literally trapped here.
At least you are young
I have to be honest, I don’t really know what people are getting at with this one, I can only think that they mean I am young and have the rest of my life to live? But in reality, being young does not make my situation any easier. I got sick at a really young age, I have been unable to have any sort of career, my social life is non existent, my friends have all disappeared and stopped caring, and I have no memory of a life without pain. I literally don’t know what it is like not to be in pain. i also know that even if my underlying conditions were all eventually cured, irreversible damage has been done to my body, I will never be totally well, and that’s hard to deal with when you’re only in your 20s and 30s. It also means that people tend not to believe me when I try to tell them what I have been through, people think i am too young to be as sick as I am or to have experienced everything that I have, even doctors don’t always take me seriously and many think that I don’t understand what’s happening in my own body.
At least you can do X activity
This is another one, people think that because I can do certain activities that I am fine. For example, I play the flute, I love it, its one of my favourite things, so people think that means my illnesses don’t bother me, or that I shouldn’t be upset about the things I can’t do.
I don’t like to focus on it, but the hard truth is that the list of things I can’t do is a lot, lot longer than the list of things that I can do, and the list of things I can’t do is getting longer all the time. Even the things I can do are dependent on how i feel that day, that hour, that minute, some days I can’t do anything other than curl up on the sofa and try to stay hydrated. There is also an element of just stubbornness a lot of the time, sometimes I have to prioritise my mental well being and I push myself physically to something that will make me happy. This doesn’t mean I am not struggling or not in pain and it’s a really fine balance between the two things.
These are just a few of the examples that I hear on a regular basis, there are many more ways that this kind of comment can be made, and while often well meaning, many of them can feel dismissive and as though the person making them doesn’t really understand.
Next time you are talking to someone who is expressing how they feel or talking about something they are going through, listen and be compassionate, and think very carefully before starting a sentence with “At least”.
